SS

SHIVAM SINGHAIR 73· 2024

Question Q.4GS2GS2

How is Indian judicial system different from that of the USA? Should India move towards a more federal model of judicial system?

Open scan (p.7)

Introduction

India has adopted the integrated judicial system with Supreme Court at the helm and HC & SC Subordinate courts at record stages. Whereas, USA has independent judiciary for Centre & State - Federalism & Judiciery.

35 words

Main Body

India vs USA Judicial System Comparison: India: SC, HC, Subordinate courts (integrated hierarchy) USA: Centre Supreme Court with separate judiciary (separate judiciery for each state) Benefit of federal Judiciary in India: Protecting the interest of states, reduce the uniformity structure, judiciary independence to the states, will become harder to undermine unity integrity or the nation, cooperative federalism.

Benefits of federal judiciary: Protecting the interest of states, reduce the uniformity structure, judiciary independence to the states, will become harder to undermine unity integrity of the nation, cooperative federalism Challenge of federal judiciary in India: Being a culturally & socially diverse country, it will be difficult to have separate courts for each state, will become harder to undermine unity integrity of the nation, cooperative federalism Way forward: Rather than having a dedicated federal judicial system, India should have a participative judiciary to accomodate the views of states.

— SHIVAM SINGH · AIR 73

145 words1 paragraphs

Conclusion

Should India move towards more federal judicial system: Rather than having a dedicated federal judicial system, India should have a participative judiciary to accommodate the views of States.

28 words

Diagram

Comparison chart showing India's integrated judicial system vs USA's federal judicial system with hierarchical structure

Steal this copy's techniques PremiumAI pulls out the reusable moves — pick the ones you want as flashcards
Compare my answer PremiumSee where this topper beats you

Topper

SHIVAM SINGH

AIR 732024

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Comparison of Indian Constitutional Scheme with Other Countries

Forms of Government

Comparison of judicial systems - India vs USA

Writing Stats

208

Total words

1

Paragraphs

analytical and prescriptive

Tone

Linked PYQ

5. Answer the questions that follow this passage : 10x5=50 It is worth attempting some head-on thoughts about 'meaning'. Confronted with passages of text you may sometimes face a choice between leading questions : 'what does it mean' versus 'how does it work'. It will be evident that words and phrases carry lexical meanings, sometimes in multiple array of possible signifying activities, sometimes also echoing other literary or historical usage. It will be evident too that what words mean is a different question from what a text-passage means; or what are the meanings at work in a whole literary composition, its thematic conflicts and developments and layers of interpretation. Also a further complication arises when we speak of what a person means, of his or her intention to be understood in a certain way, through speech or action; thus concerning Cordelia's silence in King Lear we may ask two slightly but importantly different questions : what does her silence mean, and what does she mean by her silence. In drama, these issues can be especially acute : what a particular speech 'means' will vary amongst its onstage auditors, some of whom may be more inward than others with part hidden purposes; and for the larger audience an initial array of distinct possible or probable meanings may be modified in retrospect by later disclosures or the 'dramatic irony' of subsequent events. It is fairly unlikely that questions of the playwright's own meaning or meaning-intention will feature strongly in this interplay of interpretation, though the choice of topic may indicate certain possible motives in the context of the times. Where personal character is represented as a focus for point-of-view interaction, as in narrative fiction, again what is meant may be an aspect of what this person means, in speech and action, or what this person is capable of successfully wishing to mean, depending on self-knowledge and expressed in the sense of actions consequentially undertaken, such actions then interpreted by others from differing viewpoints along significantly divergent lines. The resulting social complex of behavior, and the novelist's construction of an extended meaning-process in many strands, give the reader much work for imaginative and emotional intelligence, for sympathy tempered by judgment. Linguists and philosophers of language, and even lawyers, sometimes speak of 'plain sense', normative or 'ordinary-language' meaning; but students of literature know well that literary language is not ordinary, even when it adopts for stylistic purposes the speech patterns of natural utterance. Patterns of symbolism or constructed allegory, especially in pre-modern works, or tragic foreclosure in tightly plotted drama, may also require us to read for the sense of the design along more or less genre-specific lines of construal, just as earlier communities once read the pattern of daily events in terms of a directing providence. Both grammar and syntax inflect the stylistic pitch and meaning-effects of writing, and formal devices like prosody and meter and figuration will alert the reader to further aspects of meaning carried by structure and form—bringing into view what may be meant by 'carried' in this context. Richness of meaning may challenge or even defeat coherence of design; or it may reveal ordered depths of multiple significance (polysemy, ambiguity), or layers of structure and structure-echo, so that successive readings and succeeding generations of readers can discover constantly new insights and rewards. (a) What possible meanings exist beyond mere lexical meaning? (b) How differently significant are the two questions concerning Cordelia's silence in King Lear? (c) What special meaning to a speech does 'dramatic irony' give? (d) In what way is the meaning of a character's utterance limited and limiting in narrative fiction? (e) Explain the phrase 'the sense of the design'.

50M2013Answer the questions