VT

Varun TokasAIR 117· 2023

Question 12GS4GS2

ABC मिठी की नगर आयुक्त के रूप में आपको एक चुनौतीपूर्ण नैतिक दुविधा का सामना करना पड़ा है। राज्य सरकार ने एक Smart City project को मंजूरी दी है, जिसमें एक multi-lane expressway और modern commercial complexes का निर्माण किया जाएगा। परियोजना का उद्देश्य आर्थिक गतिविधि को बढ़ाना, शहरी गतिशीलता को बढ़ाना, और आवास निवेश को सुविधाजनक बनाना है। हालांकि, यह expressway पुरानी city area से गुजरेगा, जो centuries-old heritage buildings, temples, और a community of artisans पर निर्भर है जो अपनी आजीविका के लिए पर्यटन and handicrafts पर निर्भर हैं। विशेषज्ञों की चेतावनी है कि निर्माण कार्य से ऐतिहासिक ढांचों का विध्वंस और पारंपरिक craftsmenका विस्थापन होगा, जिससे community की विरासत को खतरा है। इसके विपरीत, business groups, real estate developers, और political leaders तर्क देते हैं कि शहरी विकास essential है progress के लिए और विकास concerns को बाधित नहीं करना चाहिए। Conversely, business groups, real estate developers, and political leaders argue that urban development is essential for progress and should not be obstructed by conservation concerns. Priya must navigate these conflicting interests, ensuring that the government's urban development agenda is implemented while also safeguarding the city's cultural heritage and the livelihoods of vulnerable communities. (a) Identify the key stakeholders involved in the case and analyze their respective interests. (b) Discuss the ethical dilemmas faced by Priya in balancing urban development, heritage conservation, and the rights of local communities. (Answer in 250 words)

Open scan (p.53)

Main Body

The situation is a classic example of progress over culture and shows the side-effect on culture and habitual industry caused by urban development.

a) (1) Priya - Municipal Commissioner

Ensure economic development at ABC City

Manage interests of local artisans with urban infrastructure plans

Preserve community bonding and cultural heritage

2Citizens of old city area

Adds live in old city area and do not want to get displaced

Benefit from cultural heritage and do not want to lose cultural identity

3Artisans of city

Depend upon oldacity for livelihood and income

Want to protect craft and maintain

Depend upon oldacity for livelihood and income

Want to protect craft and maintain

3Artisans of city

Depend upon oldacity for livelihood and income

Want to protect craft and maintain

4Business groups and real estate developers

Seek profitable ventures and look forward to development

Position ABC as model for sustainable urban development.

b) The ethical dilemmas:

1Progress vs. Culture and shows the side-effect on culture and habitual industry caused by urban development.
2Heritage, Conservation, and Livelihood: Government has approved a Smart City project, which includes the construction of a multi-lane expressway and modern commercial complexes. The project aims to boost economic activity, enhance urban mobility, and attract investment, positioning ABC as a model for sustainable urban development. Priya must navigate these conflicting interests, ensuring that the government's urban development agenda is implemented while also safeguarding the city's cultural heritage and the livelihoods of vulnerable communities.

The situation is a classic example of progress over culture and shows the side-effect on culture and habitual industry caused by urban development.

a) (1) Priya - Municipal Commissioner

Ensure economic development of ABC City

Manage interests of local artisans with urban infrastructure plans

Preserve community bonding and cultural heritage

2Citizens of old city area

Ads live in old city area and do not want to get displaced

Benefit from cultural heritage and do not want to lose cultural identity

3Artisans of city

Depend upon oldacity for livelihood and income

Want to protect craft and maintain

— Varun Tokas · AIR 117

364 words10 paragraphs
Examiner score
0.8/10

Open original scan

Page 53

Steal this copy's techniques PremiumAI pulls out the reusable moves — pick the ones you want as flashcards
Compare my answer PremiumSee where this topper beats you

Topper

Varun Tokas

AIR 1172023

Subject & Paper

GS4GS2

Topic

Urban Development and Cultural Heritage

Smart City Projects and Community Rights

Heritage Conservation vs. Urban Development Dilemma

Writing Stats

364

Total words

10

Paragraphs

analytical

Tone